Mulder and Scully have one more case in them, and Chris Carter says he already knows what it is. The X-Files creator told Page Six he would take that story as a series or as a movie, but not until Ryan Coogler’s Hulu version has had its turn in front of an audience.
“I think we have to wait until the Coogler show finds its audience,” Carter said, speaking while promoting his new film Queens for a Day. On the sequel itself he was plainer: “I’d love to do it as a series or as a movie.”
The Ending Was Already Built Into the Revival
Carter says the groundwork is on screen. “I went to great lengths with four episodes during the last two reboots to set up [a new] story,” he told the outlet, “whether it be a movie or a limited series.” He did not name the four episodes. He did say this: “I know how it continues.”
Seasons 10 and 11 ran on Fox in 2016 and 2018 and left the big questions open, chief among them whether Scully’s pregnancy was ever what it appeared to be and what became of William. Carter has said he was satisfied with the season 11 finale as an ending for the series, which is why the pitch now is an addition rather than a repair.

Coogler’s Version Is Already Cast
Hulu handed Coogler a full series order in October, with Himesh Patel and Danielle Deadwyler playing the agents who reopen the long-shuttered division. Jennifer Yale is the showrunner, Coogler wrote and directed the pilot, and Carter is an executive producer on it. That last credit makes the waiting more awkward than it sounds: the show he is standing aside for carries his name.
Disney “could have done whatever they wanted,” he said. “They own the show.” His conversation with Coogler was “more of a courtesy call,” and he drew the line in one sentence: “I didn’t necessarily hand him the reins.” What Coogler has, by Carter’s description, is a continuation rather than a reset. “He is picking up where we left off with a different approach to the idea, the concept, and the soul of the show.”
Two Shows, One Pair of Agents
The complication is that Coogler may want Mulder and Scully too. Carter said in August that Gillian Anderson would be back as Scully for the Hulu series, according to ScreenRant, and he has assumed David Duchovny would follow. Hulu has announced no returning cast from the original run, and Carter now says he does not know what Coogler’s team intends to do with either of them.

Carter has also said he will not make his version without the two of them. His R-rated recut of The X-Files: I Want to Believe arrived this year and remains the only new Mulder and Scully release of any kind since 2008, which is a long time to sit on an ending you say you have already written.