The 10 Most Overrated Movies of the Last 10 Years

There are a lot of ways to measure a movie’s success. A movie can be a “hit” at the box office if it sells a lot of tickets and earn more money than it cost to make. Or it might be called a “critical hit,” if it earns an overwhelming majority of positive reviews on Rotten Tomatoes. It can become a literal winner if it takes home some gold at the Oscars.

Any of those successes require a consensus from a large group of people: Ticket buyers, film critics, or Academy voters, respectively. But even in those cases, there are outliers who disagree with the majority. And for today’s list here at ScreenCrush, I am the outlier — because I’m the one picking ten “overrated” films released by major studios and streamers over the last 10 years.

I recognize that labeling a film as “overrated” is a subjective value within a subjective value. And not every movie on my list is overrated in precisely the same way. Some were massively popular blockbusters, generating hundreds of millions of dollars at the box office. Others were critical favorites, adored by the vast majority of reviewers. A few were major winners at the Oscars — one even won the Academy Award for Best Picture of the year. (Obviously that film wouldn’t have gotten by my vote … but the Academy, in their infinite wisdom, have chosen not to invite me into its membership. Rude.)

Remember: These ten selections below are just my opinion. Yours may differ. And if the notion of picking “overrated” movies makes you angry on principle, just go read my list of the underrated movies of the last ten years instead.

READ MORE: The 10 Best Action Movies of the Last 10 Years