We have answered the question of how far Moana will go.
Answer: Not as far as expected.
Despite its connection to one of the most popular animated movies of the 21st century — and the presence of one of the animated version’s big stars — 2026’s live-action remake of Moana sank to the bottom of the box-office ocean over the weekend. According to estimates, the film earned approximately $43 million in its first three days of release.
Previously, experts predicted the film would earn at least $60 million over the weekend, with some predictions suggesting it could earn well above that. Instead, its $43 million is a fair amount under the $56.6 million the original animated Moana earned in its opening weekend a decade ago, and barely a third of what Moana 2 took in during its debut in theaters back in 2024. That film did an astounding $139.7 million in its opening weekend.
READ MORE: The Worst Remakes of the Best Movies
Those who did see Moana in theaters seemed to enjoy it; they gave the film a solid A- rating on CinemaScore. And it did earn $52 million in international theaters. But there’s no way this was the outcome that Disney wanted.
Why did the movie struggle in theaters? To me, there are two obvious reasons. One: Moana came out just 10 years ago — and Moana 2 came out just two years ago! — way sooner than is typical on Disney’s live-action remake schedule. (Years between Cinderellas: 65. Years between Pete’s Dragons: 39 years. Even Lilo & Stitch was 23 years.) Moana is still comparatively fresh in everyone’s minds, and that’s not even considering the fact that it’s available whenever kids want to watch it on Disney+.
The other major factor: Competition. For the first time in quite a while, families actually have a lot of options to choose from in theaters. Toy Story 5 came out less than a month ago and Minions & Monsters debuted just last weekend. That family audience got split three ways last weekend, and a lot of those folks decided they could wait on Moana.
Does this affect Disney’s plans to make more live-action remakes? I doubt it. They’re already making one of Tangled, which is only a few years older than Moana. The animated version of that story opened in theaters in 2010.
The Best Letterboxd Reviews
We picked 25 of our favorite, funniest, wittiest reviews on the movie app.